Supplements Women in Their 40s Shouldn’t Overlook

I don’t know about you, but when I hit my 40s, I started noticing things I had never paid attention to before. My cycles weren’t the same, sleep became trickier, energy wasn’t as steady, and even simple things like bouncing back after a cold or workout felt… different.

And here’s the thing: nobody really talks to us about this stage. It feels like you’re left to figure it out on your own. But the truth is, a few key supplements can make a big difference in helping your body feel supported while everything is shifting under the surface.

I’m not about to gatekeep the things that have actually helped me — here’s what’s earned a permanent spot on my shelf.

Quick note before we dive in: I’m not a doctor, just a woman in her 40s sharing what’s worked for me. Always check with your own healthcare provider before starting anything new, especially supplements.

The items listed above are accompanied by affiliate links, meaning I earn a small commission if a purchase is made through my links. This has no impact on the cost to the consumer. I link to products this way whenever possible, and it has no bearing on the products I choose to review or recommend.

1. Magnesium Glycinate – Your Nighttime Best Friend

If you’re tossing and turning at night, you’re not alone. Sleep disturbances creep up during this stage of life thanks to hormones and stress. And honestly — can we laugh/cry for a second? I finally got my kids sleeping through the night (or at least close to it), and now my own hormones are the ones keeping me awake. The irony is not lost on me.

Magnesium glycinate is one of the gentlest, most absorbable forms of magnesium — and when I take it before bed, I can actually feel my body relax.

It’s not just about sleep either. Magnesium also supports mood, muscle recovery, and blood sugar balance (another thing that gets trickier in your 40s). Think of it as a calming mineral your body is probably craving.

My pick: Nature’s Bounty High Absorption Magnesium Glycinate

2. Vitamin D + K2 – The Power Pair

Here’s a confession: my vitamin D levels were always low, no matter how much I supplemented. I could practically live in the sun, and my bloodwork would still come back screaming “deficient.” It wasn’t until I started pairing vitamin D with K2 that I noticed a real difference.

Vitamin D supports immunity, bone health, and mood — all things that matter more than ever right now. K2 helps your body actually use that vitamin D effectively by directing calcium where it belongs (your bones) instead of letting it settle in places it shouldn’t.

So now, instead of feeling like I’m popping vitamin D for nothing, I finally see my numbers move.

My pick: Vital Nutrients Vitamin D3 + K2, or if you want a liquid version, THORNE - Vitamin D + K2 Liquid with a metered Dispenser

3. Ovasitol – For Hormones and Blood Sugar Balance

This one deserves its own spotlight. Ovasitol is a blend of myo-inositol and d-chiro-inositol, and while it’s often talked about for PCOS, it’s also a quiet hero for women entering perimenopause.

Why? Because this is the decade when insulin resistance can start creeping in — even if you’re eating the same way you always have. Suddenly, the scale doesn’t budge as easily, your cycles feel unpredictable, and your body feels like it’s working against you. Ovasitol helps improve insulin sensitivity and supports more regular cycles.

For me, it was a game-changer for helping my body feel more “in rhythm” again instead of unpredictable. And honestly? Anything that makes my cycles less of a guessing game and more tolerable is a win in my book.

My pick: Ovasitol or Ovasitol Plus if you want some extra benefits for metabolic health.

4. Omega-3 Fatty Acids – Brain, Heart, and Joint Support

This is one I think every woman in her 40s should at least consider. Omega-3s (from fish oil or algal oil if you prefer plant-based) support heart health, brain function, joint comfort, and even help calm inflammation.

I notice a difference in how “creaky” my joints feel when I’ve been consistent with them. Plus, let’s be real — with everything else on our plates, protecting long-term heart and brain health feels more important than ever.

Look for a high-quality, third-party tested supplement so you know you’re actually getting what’s on the label without the fishy fillers.

My pick: Theromega (Theralogix rigorously tests its supplements, which is why I confidently recommend them. It's crucial to ensure your fish oil is free from high mercury levels.)

5. Probiotics – For Gut and Immunity

Gut health becomes more important in your 40s than most of us realize. A high-quality probiotic can help balance your gut bacteria, support digestion, and even strengthen your immune system.

My tip? Go for a probiotic that’s refrigerated — they’re often more potent and stable. So check your local Whole Foods or order from a reputable online retailer that will mail it with a cold pack. It’s one of those behind-the-scenes helpers that you may not notice right away, but you’ll be glad you have on your side when digestion or immunity feels a little “off.”

6. Fiber – The Unsung Hero

Here’s something I didn’t expect in my 40s: digestion can get a little stubborn. Fiber makes a huge difference — not just for keeping things moving, but also for balancing blood sugar and even supporting hormone health.

I’ve tried a few different kinds. Metamucil worked, but honestly? It left me bloated and gassy. Benefiber has been much gentler on my stomach while still doing the job. The good news is there are options, so you can experiment until you find one that fits your body best.

My pick: Benefiber or Metamucil

7. Keep in Your Back Pocket: D-Mannose or Cranberry Pills

Here’s the real talk: as our hormones shift, we become more prone to urinary tract infections. And nobody warns you about how frustrating (and painful) that can be.

The kicker? Half the time you finally drag yourself to the doctor, they hand you an antibiotic that not only wipes out the bad bacteria but the good bacteria too — and some even come with black box warnings. Because apparently in your 40s, you don’t just get the UTI, you get the fine print too.

That’s why I keep D-mannose or cranberry supplements on hand. They’re not a cure, but they can support urinary tract health and may help prevent those repeat infections. Think of it like having a little insurance policy for your body when things feel off.

My pick: D-mannose and Cranberry UTI Prevention Bundle

You’re Not Alone

If you’ve been feeling like your body is changing and you’re just supposed to figure it out by yourself — you’re not crazy, and you’re definitely not alone.

Your 40s are a season of transition, but with the right support, they don’t have to feel overwhelming. Supplements like magnesium glycinate, vitamin D + K2, Ovasitol, omega-3s, probiotics, fiber, and even D-mannose or cranberry can help you feel more like you again.

So next time you’re restocking your wellness shelf, think of this list as your midlife toolkit. And if nobody else has said it lately: you’re doing a great job navigating this season. Truly.

Pin for Later >>

---